[Reporter’s notebook] Psychological, human-rights concerns raised over electronic wristbands

Posted on : 2020-04-14 18:40 KST Modified on : 2020-04-14 18:40 KST
Being quarantined severely impacts mental health, medical journal says
A quarantine facility at the National Medical Center
A quarantine facility at the National Medical Center

Being quarantined can lead to fears of infection, financial loss, stigmatization, post-traumatic stress disorder, insomnia, emotional exhaustion, and anger, researchers concluded in a recently published journal article.

These are some of the psychological problems that can be faced by people quarantined for infectious diseases such as COVID-19, warned a paper published in medical journal the Lancet at the end of February. The paper was submitted by a research team led by Samantha Brooks, a post-doctoral researcher at the department of psychological medicine at King’s College London.

The researchers emphasized that, while self-quarantine may be a necessary measure for preventing the spread of disease, it should be approached carefully. Problems created by the failure to take care of the psychological health of quarantined individuals could impose a long-term burden on the entire state’s public health and medical systems, they advised.

As the coronavirus pandemic drags on, health experts are focusing more attention on the psychological health of people in self-quarantine and residents in regions that have been locked down. In an Apr. 9 contribution to the World Economic Forum, Elke Van Hoof, a professor of health psychology at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB), stressed the need to focus on the psychological health impact on the lockdown and quarantine policies being implemented in many countries.

In South Korea, one individual in their 20s committed suicide while in self-quarantine on Apr. 8 after arriving in South Korea from Europe on Apr. 4. Police are currently ascertaining the exact reasons for the suicide, but experts have been cautiously suggesting that psychological health may have been a factor, explaining that “the isolation situation may influence suicidal urges.” Because of the significant burden that quarantining places on psychological health, local governments in Seoul, Sejong, and elsewhere have been establishing psychological support systems for individuals in self-isolation.

Civil society fiercely objects to electronic wristbands, worrying about exacerbation of mental health burdens

Recently, controversy has been raging over the government’s plan to use electronic wristbands on individuals who violate self-quarantine guidelines. Civil society objected fiercely to the announcement of plans to apply “security bands” to monitor those violating quarantine guidelines -- accounting for just 106 of the 56,856 total people currently in self-quarantine as of Apr. 10.

The fear is that the social stigma of wearing an electronic wristband could exacerbate the psychological health burden of being quarantined. Authorities explained that the measure had already been adopted in Hong Kong -- but even there, wristbands have only applied to Hong Kongers arriving from overseas for two-week periods. The measure was adopted as a supplement due to the inability to stop overseas Hong Kongers returning home.

While the government has since altered its approach to apply only to those violating quarantine guidelines, even that approach has been questioned on legal grounds. Is it too much to ask for a cautious approach to disease prevention that takes the feelings of self-quarantine individuals into account?

By Lee Jae-ho, staff reporter

Please direct comments or questions to [english@hani.co.kr]

button that move to original korean article (클릭시 원문으로 이동하는 버튼)

Related stories

Most viewed articles