[Reporter’s notebook] Hypocrisy and injustice in Europe’s treatment of migrants

Posted on : 2023-10-20 17:00 KST Modified on : 2023-10-20 17:00 KST
It’s impossible to talk about Europe’s current migrant issues without reflecting on the West’s colonization of Africa
Around 11 am on Oct. 4, a boat full of migrants that set off from Tunisia arrived at the Favaloro Pier on Lampedusa. At the beach down the shore from the pier, tourists can be seen swimming and sunbathing. (Noh Ji-won/The Hankyoreh)
Around 11 am on Oct. 4, a boat full of migrants that set off from Tunisia arrived at the Favaloro Pier on Lampedusa. At the beach down the shore from the pier, tourists can be seen swimming and sunbathing. (Noh Ji-won/The Hankyoreh)

“When an Italian is going to Africa, a lot of the times, they don’t need a visa. They just have to buy a plane ticket. In contrast, an African has to go through countless bureaucratic processes in order to come to Europe. What distinguishes the two? This is the injustice that exists right now.”

This is what 28-year-old Salih Haila told the Hankyoreh on Lampedusa, Italy’s southernmost island where more than 130,000 migrants to Europe arrived from Africa this year alone. For two years, he worked on this island confronted with a humanitarian emergency, helping rescue migrants crossing the Mediterranean. He himself is a second-generation immigrant who came to Italy from West Africa with his parents. For most Africans, passports are meaningless.

The coincidental conversation with Salih, who came to the island to commemorate the 10-year anniversary of the deaths of 368 migrants on the shores of Lampedusa Island on Oct. 3, 2013, was unforgettable. Connecting the current migrant issue with Europe’s colonization of Africa in the past, he said Europe was hypocritical for its anti-immigration policy.

“Historically, the West colonized Africa for hundreds of years. Africans were forcibly taken and exploited as Europeans pleased for free. Now, the West is sufficiently developed, and everything is good. But now they say they do not want Africans. What is this if not hypocrisy?”

Many of those who lost their lives in the coastal waters of Lampedusa 10 years ago were from Eritrea, Italy’s first colony. Starting in the 1880s, European countries competed for colonies in Africa for economic and strategic advantages.

Britain seized Sudan and most of southern Africa, while France took over western and northern Africa. Germany, Belgium, Italy, Portugal and more soon joined the “scramble for Africa,” making it so that very few nations in Africa can say they were free from colonial domination by one of the major Western European powers.

Despite this, campaigns that call migrants a threat to national interest are gaining strength across Europe.

“The media talks about migrant issues, but they don’t do a good job covering why it is that migrants are taking these risks or how their lives change when they get to Europe,” said Ali, a migrant from Mali who now runs a hostel in Sicily. “Instead, politicians create hatred and fear of migrants.”

Migrants who settle in Europe are seldom spoken of in terms of their positive contributions to society, but instead are portrayed as job-stealers and criminals. A majority of migrants make the difficult decision to give up everything they have and embark on the perilous voyage to Europe for any of a variety of reasons, including hunger, war, dictatorship, religious persecution, and the climate crisis.

That Europe needs immigrants as it deals with labor shortages due to a declining population, and that migrants play a huge role in economic development are not novel ideas. But what must not be forgotten is that all people have the right to pursue a better life.

The words of Vito Fiorino, an older resident of Lampedusa who was among the first to begin saving people from the tragic shipwreck 10 years ago, take on new weight.

“Every person should be able to live freely, fairly and safely in their own country.”

By Noh Ji-won, Berlin correspondent

Please direct questions or comments to [english@hani.co.kr]

button that move to original korean article (클릭시 원문으로 이동하는 버튼)

Related stories

Most viewed articles